Carmen
critic Reviews
, 61% Fresh Tomatometer Score- Benjamin Millepied reinvents Prosper Mérimée's tragic novella as a dance extravaganza full of sound and fury signifying a hollow emotional core, although the ravishing style is a treat onto itself.
- , Fresh Tomatometer ScoreKimberley JonesAustin Chronicle
Britell’s score super-juices the tragic pall over the film, while Barrera and Mescal channel Romeo and Juliet as the star-crossed lovers who communicate mostly in looks and the occasional pas de deux.
Read full article - , Fresh Tomatometer ScoreKevin MaherTimes (UK)
It is indeed a strange film, but not a bad one.
Read full article - , Rotten Tomatometer ScoreTim RobeyDaily Telegraph (UK)
The dancing and photography are striking, and the acting’s perfectly fine. But the sum of it all is a moony inertia, lacking any awakening spark of life.
Read full article - , Fresh Tomatometer ScoreRobyn QuickLittle White Lies
A film filled with compelling performances, but it doesn’t leave much of an impression.
Read full article - , Fresh Tomatometer ScoreCath ClarkeGuardian
It’s a heartfelt, extravagant film, swirling with melodrama and music.
Read full article - , Rotten Tomatometer ScoreAdam GrahamDetroit News
It half-works but never catches fire, and is lacking in the very elements — truth, beauty, freedom, love — it seeks to espouse.
Read full article - , Fresh Tomatometer ScoreFrancesca SteeleiNews.co.uk
This is the first film from writer/director Benjamin Millepied, a dancer and choreographer, and while it suffers from its lack of story, it’s an exciting debut effort and I look forward to seeing what he does next.
Read full article - , Rotten Tomatometer ScoreJavier OcañaEl Pais (Spain)
Long and petulant, with little text, a visualization closer to a perfume ad than a film. [Full review in Spanish]
Read full article - , Rotten Tomatometer ScoreRubén Romero SantosCinemanía (Spain)
A not so cool Carmen. [Full review in Spanish]
Read full article - , Fresh Tomatometer ScoreGissane SophiaLady Geeks Media
Melissa Barrera dazzles as brilliantly as she does in Jon M. Chu’s In the Heights, and her chemistry with Paul Mescal delivers a deeply memorable romance.
Read full article